After a touch of internet stalking, Cleo discovers her Yankees hat in an Instagram post of another girl. She's adamant that her ex, Anthony, gave it away, and she's even more determined to get it back. Despite the warnings of her skeptical best friend to just let it go, Cleo tries everything to make a principled point about reclaiming what is rightfully hers. Under the pretense of returning a broken lamp from their once-shared apartment, Cleo arrives at Anthony’s newer and much nicer place, demanding her hat. As she continues her journey in the final tailspin of their doomed relationship, it's clear that Cleo clings to a hapless hope that their relationship might just catch wind again.