Cary, a meddling twink with a penchant for chaos, gathers his friends at a vacation house for his birthday weekend, teasing a surprise game night. As he prepares for their arrival, Cary fixates on Alma's name card. A distant Alma doesn't show up until later in the day, much to Cary's chagrin. When the group settles in for the night, Cary finally reveals the nature of the game: for his 25th birthday, Cary wants his friends to tell him everything they hate about him. As the night descends into disarray, the true purpose of Cary's messy charade begins to crystallize.